Education Minister is “hellbent on wrecking all that is good in our schools” - Smith
Thursday, December 6th, 2007UUP Cllr and Education Team spokesman Marion Smith has expressed her complete frustration at the lack of clarity in Education Minister Catriona Ruane’s latest statement on the transfer procedure.
In a statement she said “This Minister has yet again shown her tendency to talk in generalities and to virtually ignore the practicalities. Her latest statement is full of fairly meaningless rhetoric and completely lacking in any sense of reality. Schools and parents are extremely uncertain about the future and this statement does nothing to clarify things for them.
“In her statement the Minister signals the end of the present transfer test. Few will regret its passing as it is clearly now well past its sell-by date. The problem is that she has still not clearly spelt out what will replace it.
She talks in very general terms about a move to key decisions being taken at the age of 14 rather than 11. However any such change would have major structural implications for schools and there is absolutely no indication of haw this would be achieved of the time scale involved and the cost. Some people have welcomed the suggestion of the change to 14 on the grounds that it is already working well in Craigavon. However in her statement the Minister clearly indicates there will be no selection even at age 14 and that completely undermines the present arrangements in Craigavon where there is selection for grammar schools at age 14.
Cllr Smith went on to suggest that the Minister had lost a golden opportunity to think radically about how the system could be changed for the better. She added, “ most of us do accept that some change is needed. However the way forward must be based on a system which effectively matches the aptitude of children with what particular schools can offer.
In her obsession with political dogma the Minister has completely ignored these more practical possibilities and seems hell bent of wrecking all that is good in our schools. She also appears to be ignoring the need for the legislative changes which will be necessary and how she can get these through the Assembly. Indeed in our wonderful new age one would have thought that a change of such magnitude would be a matter for the whole Executive rather that being decided on the whim of one somewhat detached Minister.”
Ulster Unionist North Down councillor Marion Smith has welcomed the publication by the British Medical Assocation of a report on domestic abuse and violence. The report is the work in the BMA’s Board of Science and is evidence of the seriousness with which the medical professions view the health and social impacts of domestic violence.